Under Coach Bergersen (2001 - present)

2001: Finished 12 -6 (NCLCA Most Improved Team)
Playoffs Round 1: MacArthur 13, Hewlett 6
Playoffs Round 2: Port Washington 11, MacArthur 8
All County - Jon Birsner, Jeff King
 

2002: Finished 12 -6
Playoffs Round 1: MacArthur 16, Floral Park 4
Playoffs Round 2: Lynbrook 7, MacArthur 5 (@ USMMA Kings Point)
All County - Jeff King, Jason Cappadoro, Scott Rodgers
Honorable Mention All American - Jeff King
 

2003: Finished 6 - 11
Playoffs Round 1: Division 10, MacArthur 5
All County - Scott Rodgers, Nick Tintle
 

2004: Finished 12 - 5
Playoffs Round 1: Lynbrook 6, MacArthur 5
All County - Scott Rodgers, Nick Tintle, Jim Nally
All American - Scott Rodgers, Nick Tintle
Nassau Conference B Goalie of the Year - Scott Rodgers
Nassau Conference B Midfielder of the Year - Nick Tintle
 

2005: Finished 7 - 10
Playoffs Round 1: South Side 12, MacArthur 1
All County - Scott Rodgers, Steve Waldeck
All American - Scott Rodgers (STX High School Senior Showcase Goalie)

2006: Finished 9 - 8
Playoffs Round 1: Calhoun 9, MacArthur 8 (2-OT)
All County: Steve Waldeck

2007: Finished 12 -6 (NCLOA Sportmanship Team Award)
Playoffs Round 1: MacArthur 10, Freeport 6
Playoffs Round 2 (Quarter Finals): Syosset 9, MacArthur 4 @ Hofstra University
All County - Tom Celentani, Brett Tom
NYS Scholar Athlete Team Award

2008: Finished 9-7
Playoffs Round 1: MacArthur 11, Port Washington 7
Playoffs Round 2 (Quarter Finals): Long Beach 11, MacArthur 8 @ Hofstra University
All American Finalist - Tom Celentani

2009: Finished 6-11 (NCLOA Sportmanship Team Award)
Playoffs Round 1: Plainedge 7, MacArthur 5
All County- Tom Bruno